elemental magic fantasy – Creative Cornerstones

4.5 stars!

Ironbound is my favorite read so far this year! I devoured it and then immediately read the second one, Cold Wind. I can’t wait for the third, Bloody Sands, out winter 2026!

Ironbound is a military progression fantasy about a clever young man who’s betrayed by his leaders and sold into the bottom rung of the Iron Legions – a death sentence – when a magical ceremony goes terribly wrong. Castor makes an oath of revenge, but first he’ll have to earn his friends’ forgiveness, master his strange new power, and survive the corrupt rulers who want to see his Legion dead.

This article contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Characters: 4/5

I enjoyed that Castor’s, strengths lie in his leadership skills and practical cleverness. He gains rather astounding power too, but his foundation is still one of resourcefulness coupled with people skills. I love how much of the story focused on his relationship with his childhood friend, legionnaire companions, and his commander Gaius, who was one of my favorite characters.

In progression fantasy, I hate the mc’s that have a cool, distant bravado, like nothing shakes them, and they never make relational mistakes (*cough* Solo Leveling). In Ironbound, Castor wrestled with guilt, grief, the resentment of his friends, the weight of secrets and oaths, and more. He has arguments with his friends, makes mistakes, and has to find forgiveness and learn to trust his new commanders. This rich, character-driven focus is what made this story so compelling for me.

The characters themselves aren’t necessarily the most unique. They are a bunch of teenagers running around bashing things. But the dynamic between them all is what makes the heart (reference intended) of this story. I couldn’t get into The Will of the Many because it lacked this element for me, but Ironbound hit it out of the park!

Writing and plot: 4/5

The writing is deft, handling action, introspection, dialogue, and more well. I was most impressed by the excellence of the pacing. Givler balances internal and external conflict, and mystery and character development with wonderful instinct. We learn more about the world, magic, political corruption, and ancient magic mystery one piece at a time, just enough to keep us aching to learn more, and not too much that it ever felt like an info dump.

These characters suffer a lot, but the author balances it with mini victories (increases in power, unification of their unit) that make every part of the story satisfying. These characters have a meta enemy, but also smaller antagonists who are well developed and break up the overall story. It’s rare for me to read a story where I felt like every chapter started and ended at just the right moment and every new problem and character came at the right time. Wonderful pacing! It made the experience of reading this book wonderful!

Worldbuilding: 4/5

Rome with name change, plus an elemental magical bonding system. What’s not to love? This was a well-developed system, with good limitations and clear ranks, but enough variation to leave surprises. For instance, most people the main character interacts with in this book are bound to elements that have martial potential. But people can bond to plants, abstract concepts, sound, and more, leaving a lot of potential for imagination. I was eager to discover more about the possibilities of this system and how the dead gods are involved. There’s definitely a lot to uncover!

Note: The main characters use some cultivation tactics, though mostly regular military training, to advance to higher stages of power (3 ranks total). But otherwise, this reads like normal military fantasy, so if you’re not into LitRPG, don’t worry, it’s a super fun read!

Emotional Impact: 5/5

I really cared for these characters. Man, the ending hit hard. I won’t give spoilers, but boy was I mad/sad and instantly bought and started reading book 2 because I couldn’t take it!

Castor longs to bind a Cor Heart, an otherworldly metal, that grants the ability to bind and manipulate an element.

But on the day of his trials, a mysterious attack shatters the bonding ceremony, earning him the ire of his leaders and the destruction of his family.

Conscripted into the Legions and bound to a Symbol he never wanted, Castor must survive corrupt enemies from within the Empire and terrifying magic users from without, if he is to gain his revenge.

Buy on Amazon

Sneak Peak Review of Book 2: Cold Wind

4/5 stars!

It’s rare for a sequel to feel so different from the first book, and yet still work so well. I was worried at what felt like a total reset – new side characters, new places – and thought the dynamics I’d come to love so much had been “wiped clean.” I was wrong.

Yet again, I was drawn in by how Givler creates tension, intrigue, and loyalty between characters. Castor’s new masters and mentors are fascinating, and the palpable power coming off them drew me like a magnet. I’ve always loved when characters have secrets from each other, so rather than feeling like a repetition of book 1, it felt like challenge part two, but upped a level, since these new characters are even more powerful than his last mentors.

And his new situation is a perfect setup for his long-term plans of revenge, and his unwilling investigation into the secrets of the old, “dead” gods.

Read the full review, with vague spoilers, on Goodreads.

After escaping the north, an injured Castor, presumed a criminal, is sold as a gladiator to one of the Empire’s Great Houses.

With a chance to infiltrate the heart of the Empire and finally gain revenge against his enemies, Castor agrees to serve his new lord.

But if he slips and reveals the new secrets of his Cor Heart, execution awaits. As the dead gods stir and dangerous enemies stalk his new master, Castor must consider taking a larger role in shaping the fate of his nation.

Buy on Amazon

Hi, I’m Caylah Coffeen, a freelance editor and marketer of sci-fi and fantasy books. I love reading and writing and am a follower of Jesus Christ.

I’ve worked for Monster Ivy Publishing, Eschler Editing, and Havok Magazine. Reach out to chat about books and publishing!

Thanks for stopping by my website! I hope you’ve found some helpful resources about reading, writing, and publishing. If you liked this article, here’s some more free content…